This page provides information on professional development opportunities, including mentoring programs, as well as guidance on promotion and tenure policies and procedures.
Academic promotion and tenure seek to recognize and reward faculty excellence. For purposes of promotion, excellence is defined in terms of contributions to one’s profession, rather than excellence in carrying out one’s job responsibilities, such as patient care, teaching or administration. These documents outline the standards for promotion and provide guidance for all faculty regarding promotion and tenure.
As Vice Provost for Faculty Affairs, Robert Granfield is the senior executive officer responsible to the provost for all matters pertaining to UB’s faculty. He and his staff help facilitate a culture of faculty excellence at the university in the areas of research, teaching, and service. The primary duties of the vice provost for faculty affairs include coordinating the university’s promotion and tenure process; welcoming and orienting new faculty to UB; assisting deans, department chairs, and faculty with issues associated with hiring and retention; building programs to orient new department chairs and improve their management skills; facilitating the nomination process for national, internal, and SUNY awards; and partnering with the vice provost for inclusive excellence to develop proactive strategies for enhancing faculty diversity.
This document is designed to supplement the University promotion and tenure policies, and to provide context regarding the academic responsibilities of the diverse faculty in the School of Dental Medicine, so that promotion dossiers are treated objectively and equitably during tenure deliberations at the University level.
The University at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine standards for promotion within the tenure track recognize excellence in scholarship, teaching, and service within the framework of the School’s unique clinical teaching and research environment.
Contributions in the areas of scholarship, teaching, and service are usually evident from general University guidelines. However, the University at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine places special demands on its faculty relative to the profession and the community it serves. In particular, teaching activities encompass clinical supervision as well as classroom and laboratory instruction, and service activities often include patient care. In addition to scholarship, the School of Dental Medicine recognizes contributions to the teaching of clinical dentistry and service activities involving the management of patient care clinics.
Scholarship for some faculty may involve basic science research; for others, it involves applied clinical, educational, behavioral or health policy research. Similarly, teaching may be focused predominantly in a classroom, in a research laboratory, or in a clinical environment. Service commitments might reflect areas of scholarship as well as educational programs or clinical care. In many cases, faculty have strengths across all three domains. However, the diversity among our faculty in terms of those responsibilities requires that each candidate be evaluated on an individual basis.
The balance between achievements in scholarship and teaching may vary considerably from one faculty member to another. Nevertheless, regardless of a faculty member’s activities and areas of focus, academic advancement signifies attainment of a recognized threshold of significant academic and professional accomplishment and the promise of continued professional growth. The granting of tenure is a recognition of significant accomplishment and never merely a reward for years of service.
Each candidate for promotion shall be evaluated relative to scholarship, teaching, and service criteria (refer to Appendix 1 for example evaluation criteria). All candidates are expected to demonstrate unambiguous and unequivocal achievement in all three areas. To attain tenure, a faculty member's academic work must be recognized as important and valuable to the University. For the School of Dental Medicine, that threshold is at least at the level required by other American dental schools in peer or aspirant institutions (preferably AAU public research universities).
Professional or administrative service, community service, and clinical activities are considered with any decision regarding an award of tenure. However, such activities in the absence of significant accomplishments in both scholarship and teaching do not provide sufficient basis for an award of tenure.
Candidates for promotion to the rank of Associate Professor must hold an appropriate terminal degree or have equivalent scholarly or professional accomplishments. They must also demonstrate significant achievements in teaching and scholarship extending well beyond those involved in the attainment of the doctoral degree or its equivalent. In all cases of proposed tenure as an Associate Professor, the candidate must have demonstrated a consistently high level of performance as a scholar and teacher, and sustained participation in service activities, with the potential to meet requirements for eventual promotion to Professor. Evaluation of the candidate's work must be supported by substantial evidence of peer review that has been carried out in a manner characteristic of and appropriate to the discipline.
In addition to meeting the criteria for the rank of Associate Professor, candidates for promotion to the rank of Professor must demonstrate continued achievement in their areas of expertise, and should have established a national or, where appropriate, an international reputation for leadership in their fields. They must demonstrate excellence in scholarship and in teaching, and show evidence of significant, sustained service activities. Faculty members holding this title have the primary responsibility for the scholarship of the University, and their recognition as scholars in their disciplines must be of the first rank.
School of Dental Medicine Promotion and Tenure Processes and Procedures (12/5/23).
Candidate’s Guide to Dossier Preparation.
Chair’s Guide to Dossier Preparation.
University Policies and Procedures.
These standards were reviewed by the School of Dental Medicine Promotion and Tenure Committee and approved by the SDM Executive Council on December 5, 2023. The document was created based on the Guidelines for Appointment, Promotion and Tenure, State University of New York at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine, approved by the Voting Faculty of the School of Dental Medicine in May, 1996, and serves as its replacement. It also borrows heavily, with permission, from the Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences Policies, Procedures and Criteria for Faculty Promotion adopted by its Faculty Council June 24, 2020.
Evaluation Criteria for promotion include (but are not limited to):
These are examples only, and are not to be interpreted as inclusive.
This document outlines the University at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine standards for promotion within the Qualified Academic (non-tenure) track. The school distinguishes between two designations: Clinical Educator and Research Educator (the criteria and process for promotion for faculty in the Volunteer track, not specifically referenced in this document, are identical to those for the Qualified Academic track). Clinical Educator ranks are recognized by SUNY titles of Clinical Assistant Professor, Clinical Associate Professor, and Clinical Professor. Research Educator ranks are recognized by SUNY titles of Research Assistant Professor, Research Associate Professor, and Research Professor (refer to Appendix 1 for complete list of tracks and titles).
Faculty appointed to Qualified Academic ranks (those with the prefix clinical or research) make essential contributions to the teaching, research, and service missions of the School of Dental Medicine. Although the positions and titles are qualified as being "clinical" or "research," faculty members in those ranks are academicians.
All faculty members in Qualified Academic titles are expected to contribute to teaching, scholarship, and service. Regardless of activities and focus, academic advancement signifies attainment of a threshold of meritorious academic and professional accomplishment. Thus, promotion is a recognition of significant accomplishment and never merely a reward for years of service.
Each candidate for promotion shall be evaluated relative to scholarship, teaching, and service (refer to Appendix 2 for examples of evaluation criteria). To be promoted, a faculty member's academic work must be recognized as important and valuable to the School of Dental Medicine. The Research Educator and Clinical Educator designations recognize the diversity of faculty; because of this diversity, the balance between achievements in scholarship and teaching may vary considerably from one faculty member to another. However, all candidates must provide evidence of significant contributions to scholarship, teaching, and service. The quality of those activities should be unambiguous and unequivocal.
NOTE: Promotion dossiers for candidates for Research Professor are reviewed by the President’s Review Board, and therefore the promotion process to this rank likely will be more rigorous. Consequently, candidates should refer to the SDM Standards for Faculty Promotion in the Tenure Track.
These standards were reviewed by the School of Dental Medicine Promotion and Tenure Committee and approved by the SDM Executive Council on December 5, 2023. The document was created based on previous guidelines and borrows heavily, with permission, from the Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences Policies, Procedures and Criteria for Faculty Promotion adopted by its Faculty Council June 24, 2020. The previous version consisted of a) SDM Guidelines for Promotion in the Qualified Tracks, which was approved by the Voting Faculty in 2015 and subsequently revised in 2018, 2021, and 2023. Those were formulated based on b) qualified tracks guidelines from the Guidelines for Appointment, Promotion and Tenure, State University of New York at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine, approved by the Voting Faculty of the School of Dental Medicine in May, 1996.
The University at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine recognizes three faculty tracks, as specified by the State University of New York at Buffalo (SUNY). Titles within tracks indicate rank.
Evaluation Criteria for promotion include (but are not limited to):
These are examples only, and are not to be interpreted as inclusive.
The purpose of this document is to provide specific guidance to faculty in the School of Dental Medicine regarding promotion and tenure processes and procedures. For more specific information, please refer to the University at Buffalo’s Policies, Procedures, and Criteria for Faculty Personnel Actions.
Accessed July 1, 2025, from UB's Office of Provost.
All faculty members receive an initial appointment to a specific faculty track- either Tenure or Non-tenure. All appointees must be notified of their faculty track and the employment conditions that will be applied for future promotion considerations. It is the responsibility of the department Chair to notify new faculty, in writing, of the School's and University's criteria for promotion.
Faculty members should meet with the Chair to discuss academic advancement at least annually, and preferably more frequently when working toward promotion. Those discussions should focus on strengths and areas that might be improved, as well as the anticipated timeline for promotion. The primary responsibility for initiating the promotion process rests with the individual faculty member. The procedures below should be followed for any faculty member being recommended for promotion.
The promotion procedures for faculty in the Volunteer track, not specifically referenced in this document, are identical to those for the Qualified Academic track.
Promotion to the rank of Assistant Professor in either track is made at the department level, with final approval by the Dean.
The promotion process involves review of the candidate’s dossier and a series of votes, sequentially at the Department, Promotion and Tenure Committee, and Executive Council within the School of Dental Medicine. Additional review at the University level occurs for promotions within the Academic ranks above Assistant Professor, and for candidates being considered for promotion to Research Professor. The responsibility for preparation of the promotion dossier rests with the candidate’s primary department, and consists of elements prepared by both the candidate and the Chair (refer to the Candidate Guide to Dossier Preparation and Chair’s Guide to Dossier Preparation for guidance). Dossiers submitted for review at the University level also include a recommendation letter by the Dean of the School.
This document was reviewed by the School of Dental Medicine Promotion and Tenure Committee and approved by the SDM Executive Council on December 5, 2023. The document follows the University at Buffalo Policies, Procedures, and Criteria for Faculty Personnel Action and was created to provide specific guidance to faculty members in the School of Dental Medicine regarding the promotion and tenure process.
Dossiers are prepared by the primary department. Following discussion between the candidate and the department chair regarding academic accomplishments and appropriateness for promotion, the candidate next prepares their portion of the dossier and submits that to the Chair (see Candidate’s Guide to Dossier Preparation).
The candidate is responsible for the following components of the dossier:
The chair or designee then completes the dossier assembly by adding the following elements:
Note to Dossier Assembler: The sequence of each dossier component is important, and each section requires a separate divider sheet. Please refer to the university guidelines for the Checklist for Promotion Dossiers and for specific assembly guidance.
These guidelines also apply to candidates being considered for promotion to Research Professor.
The Chair’s letter to evaluators should request that reviewers address the candidate’s suitability for promotion by addressing several topics, including but not limited to the following:
Each letter to evaluators must indicate that the evaluation letter will be held in strict confidence unless the evaluator gives written permission for the candidate to see it. An Evaluation Access Permission Form is to be enclosed with each letter of solicitation, with the evaluator indicating which of three options is preferred: that the entire letter be held in confidence; that the letter be available to the candidate with all references to the author deleted; or that the candidate may see the letter in its entirety. This form must be signed and returned with the evaluator’s letter and current biosketch. All letters received in response to the solicitation should be included in the dossier. Refusals or disregarded requests should be noted as well. Evaluation letters not accompanied by the EAP form or received with an incomplete form shall be considered confidential and not shared with the candidate.
Note Regarding Promotion to Research Professor: Research Professor promotions are reviewed by the President’s Review Board, so it is recommended that the School’s Standards for Faculty Promotion in the Tenure Track, as well as the university’s guidelines for promotion in the tenure track, be followed.
The Chair should seek evaluators who can best comment on the extent and quality of the candidate’s research or creative activity, teaching capabilities, ability to work with students, willingness and skill in working with colleagues and serving on committees, and on other public or professional service as appropriate. External reviewers for a Clinical Educator promotion are more likely to be local than those for a Research Educator promotion. The latter are expected to be more national or international. In every case, external evaluators must be disinterested.
The letter to evaluators should request that reviewers address the candidate’s suitability for promotion by addressing several topics, including but not limited to the following:
Each letter to evaluators must indicate that the evaluation letter will be held in strict confidence unless the evaluator gives written permission for the candidate to see it. An Evaluation Access Permission Form is to be enclosed with each letter of solicitation, with the evaluator indicating which of three options is preferred: that the entire letter be held in confidence; that the letter be available to the candidate with all references to the author deleted; or that the candidate may see the letter in its entirety. This form must be signed and returned with the evaluator’s letter and current biosketch. All letters received in response to the solicitation should be included in the dossier. Refusals or disregarded requests should be noted as well. Evaluation letters not accompanied by the EAP form or received with an incomplete form shall be considered confidential and not shared with the candidate.
The Chair’s letter should provide a balanced evaluation of the candidate and must consider the performance expected in relation to the responsibilities assigned. This letter of endorsement transmits the dossier to the Promotion and Tenure Committee, Executive Council, and Dean and, for tenure-track and Research Professor positions, to the President’s Review Board and University. It represents the Chair’s recommendation and should include the quantitative vote (by secret ballot) on the candidate’s promotion by the department (or ad hoc committee) and the date of the vote. The Chair should include commentary on how the vote should be understood in terms of weight and degree of departmental support. The Chair’s letter is critical, as it is the summary document at the level of the discipline. It should interpret and contextualize the candidate’s work for subsequent reviewing bodies outside the discipline and be written with great care and clarity.
The Chair’s letter should address three areas of the candidate’s contributions:
Please note the following deadlines for dossier submission to the President’s Review Board. Dossiers are due absolutely no later than these dates; earlier submissions are strongly encouraged.
| Rank | Deadline | Anticipated Appointment Date |
| Professor | October 1 | the following July 1 |
| Professor | December 1 | the following September 1 |
| Associate Professor | October 1 | the following January 1 |
All additional dossiers must be submitted no later than February 1. This is not a due date, but the last possible date for consideration of review for the academic year. Earlier submissions are strongly urged. Dossiers for all actions are accepted on a rolling basis; Full Professor cases should be prepared with this understanding in order to meet the October 1 deadline each year.
Adapted from UB Procedures for Appointment, Promotion and Tenure. Accessed July 1, 2025, at Vice Provost for Faculty Affairs website.
Each of these elements is described in detail below.
These are intended to be reflective statements and not simply a restatement of the curriculum vitae. You might consider addressing the following questions: Why are you doing these things? What are your goals? Where is this leading? Each statement should be concise, following the page limits listed below.
The teaching portfolio includes the teaching statement (described above) as well as an appendix that selectively documents course material and provides evidence of innovative teaching and other supporting materials. The entire portfolio, including the teaching statement, should be no more than 20 pages.
Appendix: This should be selective, representing your best and most important teaching accomplishments. Be focused and economical about what documentation to include. Examples:
Results of course or teaching evaluations by students should include both quantitative and qualitative evaluations of teaching effectiveness, and be presented in a standardized summary or tabular form. Classroom or clinical teaching, courses pertaining to critical review of the literature, and Continuing Education courses are all considered important teaching activities. In most cases, this should include only those courses taught within the last five years. This section must include the following:
The following may also be included, if appropriate (limit 5 pages):
DO NOT, under any circumstance, include syllabi, raw data or otherwise unedited or unabridged course evaluations. The dossier is reviewed at several levels, and such a “data dump” makes it very difficult to find and review essential pieces of the dossier.
| |||||||||||||||||||||||
The curriculum vitae, or CV, represents your academic and professional history, and is an essential part of the promotion dossier. It must be up-to-date, clear, and accurate. It should not include personal information such as marital or religious status, number of children, etc. The following guidance is excerpted from Section III, Dossier Preparation, from the University’s Procedures for Appointment, Promotion and Tenure:
The CV should include the following information:
The format of the CV is left to each individual. However, an annotated sample CV is included with the additional resources to give you an overall idea of how it might be structured.
Associate Dean for Faculty Affairs and EDI; Professor
Department of Restorative Dentistry